Susan Polizzi

Susan Polizzi, GRI
Licensed Salesperson

Phone: 585-794-2895
Fax: 585-554-4520

Sue was born and raised in the Finger Lakes Region near Canandaigua Lake where her family currently resides. She doesn’t take for granted the natural beauty that surrounds us here – the water, wilderness and fresh country air! You’ll benefit from her sales customer service experience that dates back approximately 20 years. She’s always had a love for real estate and can’t wait to hear from YOU so she can give you all the tools and knowledge necessary to buy or sell Real Estate! Call Sue today!

Established service in the FINGER LAKES REAL ESTATE AREA
Working in Ontario, Yates, Steuben & Schuyler Counties, Including…
Rushville, Gorham, Hall, Middlesex, Potter, Penn Yan, Branchport, Canandaigua, Naples, Italy, Prattsburgh, Dresden, Dundee, Watkins Glen, Hammondsport, Keuka Lake, Seneca Lake, Waneta Lake, Lamoka Lake and other areas in the FINGER LAKES REGION of NY


“I would like to thank Susan Polizzi, Dan and Sandy King and Amanda Grover for making my home purchase effortless!  Dan guided me every step of the way!  The hardest part was signing all the papers at closing!  I will recommend Amanda Grover Real Estate.”
James Rathe, Buyer in Rushville

“We were very pleased with the handling of our property listing.  Sold very quickly! Thank you very much!”
Ron and Jackie Boehlert, Sellers in Rushville

“Amanda Grover Rest Estate, LLC, has a very good person working for them, that’s Sue Polizzi.  Smart, honest, trust-worthy, so that makes the Realty a great one to deal with. Good, honest, Hometown people to work with you.  Thank you for walking us through things we didn’t understand and handling everything you could for us.  A wonderful job!!  Thanks! When you have trust, you have peace of  mind.”
Bonnie Chappell, Seller in Canandaigua

“Sue was extremely helpful at hints to help sell the house, such as paint, etc.  She was always in contact with me even through the slow winter months. I truly felt that she gave me a personal touch with all that involved the sale of my house.  I would highly recomment her to anyone who is in the market to buy or sell.  Thank you, Sue!”
Linda Chambers, Seller in Town of Milo

“Thanks for the good and personal business.  Very good experience” (Sue Polizzi)
Buyers in Town of Seneca

“We would like to thank Sue Polizzi for her promptness in selling our home.  She was upfront and honest about pricing.  She did things in a timely manner.  It was staged nicely on the web and I feel that contributed to our quick sale.  We would highly recommend Sue.”
Terry & Pam Stenzel, Sellers in Middlesex

“Sue was a tremendous help in selling land from my father’s estate.  She was patient, kind and hard working throughout the entire process.  We will use Sue for all of our real estate nees in the future.”
Scott Monagle, Seller in Naples

“Sue is an amazing woman! As well as an amazing real estate agent! :)  She knows exactly what she’s talking about and how to calm your nerves through a very stressful process.  We would like to again thank Sue for an amazing experience and always being there to answer all our questions.  Thank you, Sue.  We highly recommend you to anyone buying a home.  YOU’RE AMAZING, very professional, caring and understanding.”
Angela Pata and Chad Jones, Buyers in Prattsburg

“I can not say enough good things about Sue.  She spent countless hours working to sell my house.  The process was difficult and frustrating but she NEVER gave up!  She was also ALWAYS there to answer my questions and calm my nerves.  She is a determined, friendly, hardworking saleswoman who I now consider a friend. :)
Michelle DeBlaere, Seller in Savona

“Very happy with Sue’s work and her quick sale.  Nice person.  Very professional.  Highly Recommended!”
Robert & Caroline Mullen, Seller in Manchester

“Thank you, Thank you, Thank you! Sue was great!  My whole family loved her. She was helpful and enthusiastic.  All the other agents that I spoke with when picking up paperwork at the office were also wonderful. :)  I will remember the name Sue Polizzi when friends or family are looking to buy or sell their home!”
Savannah Lee Jones, Buyer in Gorham


“THANK YOU SO MUCH, SUE!!  Sue was absolutely great to work with!  From start to finish, Sue patiently worked with us for a year and half.  We saw 2 houses before circumstance had to put a delay on the house hunt…a year later, we picked up where we left off and it was so easy to resume our efforts.   During the whole process, she was knowledgable and patient with all of our endless questions.  It was also wonderful that we were able to do all our conversing by text messages (after the first phone call) because of my work hours and no immediate internet.”
Marsha and Jacob Tubbs, Buyers in Rushville


  Sue helped make the process of selling our land easy!  She was always available to answer questions and to provide experienced advice.  We have recommended her and the agency to other neighbors and friends.  In fact, she is now helping us sell another property!  Thanks for everything, Sue!”

The Corey Family, Seller in Canandaigua

“Our Realtor, Sue, was a wealth of information and a peach to work with.  Pleasant, straight forward and helpful.
Steve & Elizabeth Martin, Buyers in Wayne

“I would recommend Sue to anyone looking for a real estate agent.  She had a difficult task in trying to sell my large home in an area that wasn’t where many wanted to buy.  She persevered and was always available to answer a question or give me advice.  Thanks, Sue, for all of your help!”
Nancy Hamilton, Seller in Geneva

” …..I LOVE YOU guys! I could never thank you enough for your patience, commitment and friendship!
Michelle DeBlaere, Buyer in Town of Italy 

“Sue texted Chuck with updates after each showing – was open/honest and worked hard to sell our house.  Always friendly and professional – honest with us regarding pricing and if and when we should drop price.   Thanks for selling our home – all your work was much appreciate.
Chuck & Michelle Roach – Seller in Town of Jeruselum

“We were very happy with everything you did for us. We’ll recommend you to all who need your assistance. Thank you so much and for not giving up. Sue is like the little engine that could and kept working until she sold our house! Thank you!”

Doug & Dian Shekell – Seller in Town of Jerusalem

“We had a very enjoyable and positive experience with Sue, and would definitely refer you to others. Thank you for all you did for us. We are happy and seks filmi excited to be moving into the area where 2 of my brothers and a sister live.”
Melvin & Ruth Brubaker and son – Buyer in Town of Jerusalem


“We couldn’t have asked for a better experience. Sue helped us through 3 transactions in 10 months making each one as easy as possible. The combination of her knowledge, personality and determination is difficult to find today. We would undoubtedly refer her and use her again. Thanks for everything; you’re the best! ”
Kathy & Jim McShea – Sold 2 homes (Italy Valley & Greece) and bought 1 home (Potter)


“Sue was fabulous! She was knowledgeable and helpful and never “pushy.” If I texted or emailed her I got a response very quickly. She truly seemed to want to help us find what we wanted and facilitate our purchase. She was excellent and I will not hesitate to recommend her and Amanda Grover to anyone looking for a realtor. FYI Sandy King was also welcome – KUDOS to both!”
Julie Andreas – Bought in Pulteney


“Nearly a year and a half ago my wife and I started to search for our first home. We never thought it would take so long and be so exhausting. Sue was amazing. Her knowledge, professionalism and reassurance is what kept us going. We got to know each other so well and Sue started to know what we were looking for more than we did. She told us to be patient and because we listened to her advice, we now have our dream home! Sue obviously knows her way around the realty business and we will forever be grateful for all of her hard work, dedication and ‘awesomeness!’ Thanks Sue and Amanda Grover Real Estate for helping my family find their first home.”
Matt Shay – First time homebuyer


“My agent Susan Polizzi was excellent. Professionalism, knowledge, skills, follow up/follow-through certainly applies to her! She provided me wonderful guidance that made the whole process very smooth, quick and successful. I am very pleased with you agency and Susan, so glad I went with you.”
Ellen Lyttle – Sold her mother’s Rushville home.


“My agent Susan Polizzi was excellent. Professionalism, knowledge, skills, follow up/follow-through certainly applies to her! She provided me wonderful guidance that made the whole process very smooth, quick and successful. I am very pleased with you agency and Susan, so glad I went with you.”
Ellen Lyttle – Sold her mother’s Rushville home.


“Susan was incredible during our house selling process. She kept my spirits up even when the feedback wasn’t so positive. I’ll never forget her comment ‘They don’t make land anymore.’ I don’t know if she actually realizes just how good and kind she is. I’m so glad she didn’t give up and found a buyer.”
Tim and Kim Kinton – Sold in Penn Yan area




“Sue Polizzi was my agent. She worked very hard to sell my vacant lot. There were many restrictions which she researched thoroughly and finally found a buyer who could accept them. She is also helping me find a place to buy. She is very knowledgeable and has pointed out things to me that I would not have thought of. She has been very helpful and continues to be.”
Betty Hansen – Sold lot in Town of Wayne


“Very happy with your business! Not only did I sell my house with Sue, but then I found a house that Phil had listed. He has been very helpful. Sue was ready to fight for more money, but it was my decision not to counter.”
Brenda Williamson – Bought and Sold with Amanda Grover Real Estate


“Sue was great. She fit us in with my schedule and hers. She was very helpful in getting us answers to our questions and was very helpful with setting us up with the other agencies we needed to close on our house. Thank you for all you have done.”
Eric Meacham and Becky Treese – Bought Rushville Village home


“Would like to say thank you to Sue for helping with my new home purchase. Would highly recommend your agency to everyone.”
Sandy Conley – Bought in Canandaigua


“Sue did a great job start to finish and I plan to use her in the future. She is awesome!”
James Kull – Bought land in Town of Gorham


“Our agent Sue was very professional & knowledgeable. She was always available with any questions or concerns we had. Though we looked for a while she found us the perfect home that suited us and our needs. Thanks to her we are now living in our perfect first home.”
Steven Widman – First Time Homebuyers


“Sue did a great job for me, and I very much appreciate her.”
Alice Demay – Sold in Town of Gorham


“Sue, I just want to thank you so much for helping us buy this house on Gorham Road. It is everything that we imagined and more! You were patient, assuring, and knowledgeable while getting on those folks at the bank to move their butts. As some of our friends will be looking for houses in the near future, we will definitely send them your way! Thanks for doing what you do, and with a smile on your face!”
The Paddocks – Bought in Stanley


“Sue was excellent! Very professional & knowledgeable. Really enjoyed working with her. She was always prepared and on top of all the houses I was interested in seeing. I will recommend her without any reservations at all. Perfect experience.”
Christopher States – Bought in Canandaigua


“Sue was very professional. She did an amazing job showing me houses. She followed through all my questions and concerns. She is very knowledgeable about the houses. I would recommend her.”
Juanita Lloyd – Bought home in Lima


“Sue is awesome! The house buying experience was a tough process, but having her as a realtor was fabulous. She always knew what was going on with the bank, surveyors, etc. and even came out to do our final walkthrough on the week she was on vacation. I will definitely recommend her to all of our friends/family that will buy a house in the future. Thank you all so much for helping us find this great house!”
Caroline Garrett – Bought in Town of Gorham


“Sue did a professional job of assessing & marketing out two parcels. She saw and promoted the assets of the properties to potential buyers. She communicated well & kept us informed regarding conversations with potential buyers.”
Jack and Marilyn Baldridge – Sold in Town of Wayne


“Sue – We couldn’t have done it without her! She was friendly, competent, knowledgeable and dedicated. Sue went above and beyond to meet us in the evenings and keep us updated. We were able to rest assured and place our trust in her hands confidently. I would recommend her in a heartbeat (and have!). Thank you very much!”
Maria Hoover and Benjamin Galens – Bought in Penn Yan


“Sue Polizzi was absolutely wonderful. She is friendly and informative and above all, very patient. We were fussy about what we wanted and she worked with us for almost a year without complaint (and much encouragement) to help us find what we wanted. She seemed to enjoy looking at houses as much as we did and frequently got excited about various features. Her knowledge of the housing market was very helpful and in the end she got us the house we wanted at less than we expected to pay.”
David and Sharon King


“Our recent property sale was a ‘best case scenario’ in every respect, and in large part due to Sue’s expertise and skills. Thanks to her, our property sold at a higher price than we had anticipated and within a 3-month period! Her friendly and professional manner put us at ease and gave us confidence that we had made the right choice in choosing Amanda Grover Real Estate over other local realtors. Sue guided us and kept us informed through every step of the process. She was a pleasure to work with and the entire process was a very positive experience for us. We would highly recommend your agency to anyone who is looking for a realtor that will be committed to selling their property at the best possible price!”
Duane and Paulette Ayers – Sold home in Bloomfield


“Very impressed with how helpful and knowledgeable Sue was with everything. Everything was smooth and easy, she kept me informed every step of the way. Couldn’t have been more helpful. Would suggest Sue and Amanda Grover Real Estate to anyone. Thank you, Sue.”
Aaron Airth


“We had very good service. The property sold quickly. We would recommend and use Sue’s services again. Thank you for a good job.”
Jeffrey and Lutesha Watson – Sold cabin in Town of Urbana


We really enjoyed doing business with you. Sue’s services were greatly appreciated as thorough and knowledgeable. Thank you.”
Town of Benton Buyer.